MotorCaliberNHTSA Safety Index

MODEL

BMW I8 Roadster

NHTSA safety across every BMW I8 Roadster model year we cover.

Across the 2 model years of the BMW I8 Roadster we cover (2019 to 2020), no year has an NHTSA crash-test score on record. No recalls are on record across those years.

THE MOTORCALIBER REVIEW
MotorCaliber editorial Reviewed against NHTSA data 2026-07-03

The BMW i8 Roadster is a plug-in hybrid sports car that blends supercar aesthetics with cutting-edge electrified engineering, targeting well-heeled buyers who want a head-turning, tech-forward driving experience. Offered here for the 2019 and 2020 model years, it sits in a rarified segment of open-top performance vehicles where exclusivity and innovation matter as much as outright speed.

From a pure safety-data standpoint, the BMW i8 Roadster presents an unusually thin evidentiary picture, and shoppers deserve to know exactly what that means. NHTSA did not crash-test this vehicle in either the 2019 or 2020 model years we cover, so there is no star rating or Safety Index score to reference. That absence is not a red flag in itself, but it does mean you cannot lean on federal crash-test results when making a safety-based purchase decision. On the recall front, the news is genuinely encouraging: zero recalls across both covered model years. For a low-volume, technologically complex vehicle, that is a notable achievement and suggests BMW managed the production and certification process carefully for this generation. Owner complaints are nearly nonexistent, with just one total complaint on record across both years, and that single report lists zero crashes, zero fires, zero injuries, and zero deaths. These are unverified allegations, but the volume alone tells a story of a vehicle that has generated almost no documented safety concerns from the people driving it. The honest bottom line is straightforward: the i8 Roadster has a clean safety record by the metrics we can measure, but the lack of crash-test data means a critical layer of independent safety verification simply does not exist for this model.

WHAT REVIEWERS SAYReviewers generally praise the i8 Roadster for its striking, futuristic styling and the novelty of its hybrid powertrain, calling it one of the most visually dramatic open-top vehicles on the market. They tend to note that interior materials and refinement feel premium but not quite at the level of BMW's flagship models, and some find the driving dynamics more focused on theater than outright performance.

WHAT TO KNOW
  • NHTSA did not crash-test the 2019 or 2020 i8 Roadster, so no independent federal star ratings exist for this model - shoppers cannot rely on government crash-test data when assessing structural safety.
  • The i8 Roadster recorded zero recalls across both covered model years, which is a positive safety signal for a low-volume, technologically complex plug-in hybrid sports car.
  • Only one owner complaint appears in NHTSA's database for the entire 2019 to 2020 production run, with no crashes, fires, injuries, or deaths reported - an unusually quiet complaint record.
  • Because this is a niche, low-production vehicle, the overall data pool is small - the clean record may partly reflect limited exposure rather than a fully validated safety profile, so a pre-purchase inspection by a BMW-certified technician is especially worthwhile.

BY YEARI8 Roadster by model year