Tesla Model S 75d

The 2019 Tesla Model S 75D is a full-size all-wheel-drive electric sedan aimed squarely at tech-forward luxury buyers who want performance and prestige without a combustion engine. Competing against established German flagships, the Model S carved out its own lane as a genuine driver's car that also happens to be one of the most scrutinized vehicles on American roads from a safety standpoint.

At MotorCaliber, we let the federal data do the talking, and the 2019 Tesla Model S 75D has a compelling story to tell. Starting at the top: our proprietary NHTSA Safety Index scores this model at 98 out of 100, landing it firmly in the Exceptional band. That is not a number we hand out casually, and it reflects a vehicle that performs at the highest measurable tier of occupant protection. On the star-rating side, NHTSA awarded a perfect 5 out of 5 stars for rollover resistance, a meaningful result for a large sedan carrying a heavy battery pack low in the floor. Frontal and side crash ratings were not reported under the standard NHTSA protocol for this model year, which is worth noting, though the overall index score accounts for the full available picture. Perhaps the most striking data point is the recall count for the covered 2019 model year: zero. In a segment where even premium competitors routinely accumulate recall actions, a clean sheet is genuinely notable. Owner complaints total 32 across our covered window, including 4 reported crashes and 1 reported injury. These are unverified allegations as always, but the numbers are modest for a vehicle with this level of public attention. The honest bottom line is straightforward: the 2019 Model S 75D stands among the safest vehicles we have evaluated, backed by hard federal data rather than marketing language.

WHAT REVIEWERS SAYReviewers generally regard the Model S as a benchmark-setting luxury sedan that delivers exhilarating acceleration and a sophisticated technology experience. Most praise its driving dynamics and over-the-air update capability, while some note that the interior quality and user-interface approach differ meaningfully from traditional European luxury rivals. Overall sentiment toward the car is strongly positive.