MODEL
Tesla Model S P90d
NHTSA safety across every Tesla Model S P90d model year we cover.
Across the 1 model year of the Tesla Model S P90d we cover (2019 to 2019), the strongest crash-test showing is the 2019 at 98 on the NHTSA Safety Index. No recalls are on record across those years.
The 2019 Tesla Model S P90D is a full-size, all-electric performance sedan aimed at tech-forward buyers who want luxury, serious acceleration, and a strong safety reputation in one package. Positioned at the top of Tesla's flagship lineup, the Model S competes with German executive sedans while offering a distinctly Silicon Valley approach to the driving experience. It is a vehicle that has long carried outsized expectations on the safety front.
At MotorCaliber, we focus strictly on the safety picture, and the 2019 Tesla Model S P90D presents a genuinely strong one. Starting with the headline number: a 98 out of 100 NHTSA Safety Index, placing it firmly in our Exceptional band. That is a standout result by any measure. On individual crash-test scores, rollover protection earns a perfect 5 out of 5 stars, which reflects the structural advantage of a low, floor-mounted battery pack keeping the center of gravity unusually low for a large sedan. Frontal and side scores are listed as not rated in our covered data, so shoppers should note those specific directional ratings are not available here to draw on. What is equally notable is the recall count across our covered model years: zero. For a vehicle this technologically complex, a clean recall record in 2019 is a meaningful data point. Owner complaints come in at 32 total, with 4 involving reported crashes and 1 involving reported injuries. These are unverified allegations, as NHTSA notes, but they are worth monitoring. No fire complaints and no reported deaths are on record in this dataset. The bottom line is that the 2019 Model S P90D earns its Exceptional safety designation and stands as one of the stronger performers in our full-size sedan coverage.
WHAT REVIEWERS SAYReviewers generally regard the Model S as a landmark vehicle in the electric sedan segment, praising its performance, over-the-air software capability, and interior technology. Most acknowledge that the driving experience feels unlike any traditional luxury competitor. Some reviewers note that interior material quality and fit and finish have historically trailed European rivals at similar price points.
- The 2019 Tesla Model S P90D earns a 98 out of 100 NHTSA Safety Index, landing in the Exceptional band, which is among the highest scores in our full-size sedan coverage.
- Rollover protection scores a perfect 5 out of 5 stars, a result tied in part to the low center of gravity created by the floor-mounted battery pack, a structural safety benefit unique to purpose-built EVs.
- Zero recalls were recorded for the 2019 model year in our dataset, which is a noteworthy result for a vehicle with this level of software and electrical complexity.
- Thirty-two owner complaints are on file with NHTSA, including 4 reported crashes and 1 reported injury. These are unverified allegations, but shoppers should review the complaint narratives directly on NHTSA's database before purchasing.