MotorCaliberNHTSA Safety Index

MODEL

Tesla Model X P90d Safety

NHTSA safety across every Tesla Model X P90d model year we cover.

Across the 1 model year of the Tesla Model X P90d we cover (2019 to 2019), the strongest crash-test showing is the 2019 at 94 on the NHTSA Safety Index. No recalls are on record across those years.

THE MOTORCALIBER REVIEW
MotorCaliber editorial ◆ Reviewed against NHTSA data ◆ 2026-10-01

The 2019 Tesla Model X P90D is a full-size, all-electric luxury SUV built for families and tech-forward buyers who refuse to compromise on performance or space. With its distinctive falcon-wing rear doors and all-wheel-drive powertrain, it sits at the premium end of the electric SUV segment, competing on both capability and cutting-edge technology rather than conventional utility-vehicle expectations.

The 2019 Tesla Model X P90D achieved a perfect 5-star rating in all three NHTSA crash-test categories: frontal, side, and rollover. This clean sweep is particularly notable given the historical challenges tall SUVs face in rollover assessments; the Model X's low center of gravity contributes to its strong performance there. The vehicle's overall NHTSA Safety Index score of 94 out of 100 places it in the Exceptional band. The 2019 Model X P90D has no recalls on record. However, its safety profile is not without caveats. Owners submitted 73 complaints for the year. This volume includes 10 reported crashes, 3 fire allegations, and 5 injury claims. While these are unverified allegations, fire-related complaints, in particular, warrant serious consideration for any electric vehicle. The 2019 Model X P90D presents elite crash-test credentials and a clear recall record, but prospective buyers should monitor the complaint volume.

WHAT REVIEWERS SAYReviewers generally praise the Model X for its impressive straight-line performance, spacious and futuristic interior, and the theatrical appeal of its falcon-wing doors. Most acknowledge that the large touchscreen-driven cabin feels genuinely premium, though some note the software-heavy controls can require adjustment. Ride comfort and low-speed refinement draw consistent approval, while the overall driving experience is described as smooth and composed for a large SUV.

WHAT TO KNOW
  • The 2019 Model X P90D earned a 94 out of 100 NHTSA Safety Index, placing it in the Exceptional band, with perfect five-star ratings across frontal, side, and rollover crash categories.
  • Zero recalls were issued for the 2019 model year, making this one of the cleaner recall records in our covered window for this vehicle.
  • Owner complaints total 73 for the 2019 year, including 3 unverified fire allegations. Shoppers concerned about EV battery fire risk should review these NHTSA complaint filings directly before purchasing.
  • The Model X's low floor-mounted battery pack contributes to a lower center of gravity than most SUVs, which likely supports its five-star rollover rating, a rating that is genuinely uncommon in the full-size SUV class.

BY YEARModel X P90d by model year

Other Tesla models